"If the misery of the poor be caused not by the laws of nature, but by our institutions, great is our sin."
- Charles Darwin

Sep 26, 2007

The Potent Fear of Male Menopause

"Male enhancement" and reproductive senescence

Three products that profit on male insecurities (Enzyte, Viagra and Tiger Penis Wine)

In my earlier post The Evolution of Menopause I discussed how accumulating evidence suggests that reproductive senescence in women is an adaptation promoting inclusive fitness. In response Stew asked the question:

Where does this leave the so-called “male menopause”? . . . Is male menopause a real phenomenon, and if it is what could its benefits be to survival?

I confess that I had never even heard of male menopause before, so this question intrigued me. A quick Google search revealed an onslaught of online “health” sites ready to sell me a host of products to fight this, previously unknown, affliction. These ranged from “new super potent herbal formulations” to “pure potent 200:1 Tongkat Ali Extract” (whatever the hell that is) to the more general “Ultimate Male Potency Booster”. I think I’m noticing a trend in their advertising approach.

Even Harvard Health Publications announces “Is There a Male Menopause: Will Hormones Help?” Apparently we don’t even need to know if there is an actual problem before jumping to an expensive cure. However, after a great deal of discussion about the slow decline of testosterone in men after the age of 40 the good doctors state:

“A 1% yearly drop in testosterone production is imperceptible at first, but by the age of 70, the average man’s testosterone production is 30% below its peak. . . . Despite the obvious appeal of testosterone replacement for older men, most doctors advise against it.”

Their prescription: eat a balanced diet and get more exercise.

So while male menopause seems to have more to do with men’s desire to be 25 forever and less to do with an actual physiological condition (remember, in women menopause is a rapid event that is confined to a specific age window) there is something to this evolutionary question. Why do men undergo a decline in testosterone at all? If evolutionary fitness means leaving the most offspring, wouldn’t the 90-year-old with the enormous Enzyte grin be the ultimate example in "survival of the fittest"?

The answer has to do with life history theory, or evolutionary cost-benefit analyses. Testosterone has numerous behavioral effects, not least of which are risk taking and aggression. Writing in the journal Evolutionary Anthropology, Richard G. Bribiescas shows how among Ache foragers in Paraguay male reproductive value (i.e. what women want) is greatest between the ages of 18 and 30. During this period, Bribiescas euphemistically notes, “males exhibit an acute spike in mortality.”

In other words, males are willing to take excessive risks (or, in rare cases, even take someone out) in order to have a better shot with the ladies. It is during this same period that male testosterone is at its peak. However, it probably wouldn’t be in an individual’s long-term reproductive interests if they continued such behaviors once they were a successful father or grandfather. As it turns out, this is the pattern seen in many other species.

Human male senescence exhibits characteristics that are like those that occur in most mammals. As in other primates, human gamete production is continuous, robust, and relatively invariant with age. However somatic deterioration seems to reflect changes in investment away from reproductive effort to survivorship.

So the evolutionary strategy has been to invest heavily in reproduction during early adulthood and then to focus on yourself and your children in later years. So perhaps testosterone declines over time because in those individuals where it did the end result was having more children with those same genes than in the men who continued to display risky behaviors. While our culture encourages men to be young forever, our evolutionary history suggests this is ultimately a failing strategy.

As for male menopause, there doesn’t appear to be much to it. However, the obsession with male potency has long been a successful marketing ploy. In the Victorian era men would pay to have regular injections of crushed goat testicles and in cultures around the world men imagine that eating the reproductive organs of other animals will somehow provide power to their own. It’s all a load of hooey. But, at least with the “super potent herbs” you might get some of the vitamins that Harvard’s health specialists recommend.


Richard G. Bribiescas (2006). On the evolution, life history, and proximate mechanisms of human male reproductive senescence. Evolutionary Anthropology 15(4):132-41. doi: 10.1002/evan.20087

The Potent Fear of Male MenopauseSocialTwist Tell-a-Friend


Anonymous said...

The Herbal levitra ED remedy, re-enhances the blood flow adjusting the circulatory system, improves sexual performance and eliminates erectile dysfunction. Improves the mental status with its powerful ingredients makes you get rid of depression, anxiety and other mental discomfort sensations generated by ED. Herbal medicine provided us the method to create safe, efficient and cost-effective herbal impotence pills.

Anonymous said...

After obtaining a prescription of medicine to treat erectile dysfunction such as viagra or Cialis from the doctor, you need to find out a suitable pharmacy that sells authentic Viagra. However, you can also buy Viagra online straight from your home just by logging into and ordering Viagra online. Buy Viagra from this online drug store; administer the medicine properly in accordance with the instructions of the doctor and ensure success in your war against erectile dysfunction.

Anonymous said...

The physical and psychological causes of erectile dysfunction interact. For instance, a minor physical problem that slows sexual response may cause anxiety about maintaining an erection. The resulting anxiety can worsen erectile dysfunction.

Anonymous said...

Erectile dysfunction can give depression and vice a versa. Both these situations are highly prevalent among men and the conditions coexist and interact in several ways that remain unclear.

Eric Michael Johnson said...

I think all of these advertisements just emphasize my point.